John Randy Sawyer is a Shareholder and member of the firm’s Construction Litigation Group. Mr. Sawyer has been practicing for fifteen years and has developed during that time extensive experience litigating in state and federal courts in New York and New Jersey. Mr. Sawyer concentrates his practice in construction litigation, including defective workmanship claims, design errors and omissions, product liability, breach of contract, insurance coverage litigation and appellate practice. Mr. Sawyer has represented developers, general contractors, subcontractors, condominium associations and homeowners in cases involving a wide variety of structures, ranging from single family homes to twenty-plus story high rises. Mr. Sawyer is the co-founder of www.ConstructionLitigationLawBlog.com.
Mr. Sawyer’s construction litigation experience is bolstered by his studies in construction related fields. Mr. Sawyer studied architecture at the New Jersey Institute of Technology’s School of Architecture in Newark, New Jersey for two years. Mr. Sawyer also received extensive training in building envelope inspections at the Exterior Design Institute in Virginia Beach, Virginia.
Mr. Sawyer has extensive trial experience. He served as lead counsel in Camelot Condominium Association v. Dryvit Systems, Inc. et al, a product liability trial which resulted in a jury verdict finding that Dryvit, a construction product manufacturer, violated the New Jersey Consumer Fraud Act. This verdict was the first of its kind in New Jersey. Mr. Sawyer also served as lead counsel in Renaissance Condominium Association v. Wickes Direct et al, a five month trial that resulted in a multi-million dollar jury verdict against a lumber supplier.
Mr. Sawyer also has extensive appellate practice in the area of construction defect litigation that includes the following appeals:
- Served as counsel to Amicus Curiae Community Associations Institute in the matter of Port Liberte Homeowners Association Inc. et. al. v. Sordoni Construction Company, which resulted in an Appellate Division decision expanding condominium owner’s rights under consumer protection laws.
- Served as counsel to Amicus Curiae Homeowners Against Deficient Dwellings, Inc. in the matter of Dean v. Barrett Homes, involving the application of the economic loss doctrine to construction defect cases.
- Served as lead appellate counsel in Marrone v. Greer & Polman Const., Inc., involving the interplay of the product liability act and the economic loss doctrine in residential construction.
- Served as lead appellate counsel in Port Liberte II Condo. Ass’n v. New Liberty Residential Urban Renewal Co., LLC, which resulted in an Appellate Division decision of first impression holding that developers, contractors and other defendants cannot enforce condominium by-laws against owners of units in the condominium.
- Served as lead appellate counsel in Fairview Heights Condo. Ass’n v. R.L. Investors, which resulted in a decision by the Appellate Division holding for the first time that New Jersey’s Statute of Repose can be equitably tolled upon a showing of extraordinary circumstances.
Mr. Sawyer has been involved in construction litigation matters involving a wide variety of construction products and improvements to real property, including:
- Exterior Insulation and Finish System (EIFS) products
- Roofing materials including clay tile, concrete tile, asphalt shingles and EPDM low-slope roofing
- CPVC fire suppression systems
- Sea walls, bulkheads and revetments
- Concrete plazas, garages and foundations
- High rise curtain wall systems
- Building envelope construction, including window systems and wood, vinyl, stucco, hardwood, and stone siding
- Golf course construction, including clay pond liners and irrigation systems
- Electrical systems
- Brick cladding systems, including thin-brick products
- Fire separation assemblies
- Pre-fabricated roof and floor truss systems
- Plumbing systems
- Underground storm/sewer drainage systems
- Deck and balcony construction
Mr. Sawyer also has an extensive history of achieving favorable outcomes for the firm’s clients through his involvement as either co-counsel or lead counsel in construction litigation cases that have settled at or shortly before trial. A representative sample includes:
- $20,000,000* recovery from settlements and trial in a construction defect case for an 80 unit condominium at the jersey shore involving deficient roofs, EIFS, decks, structural framing, plumbing and other defects
- $7,250,000* settlement at trial of a complex construction deficiency case against over 30 defendants involving claims relating to roofs, EIFS, stone and decks in a 125 unit condominium;
- $6,000,000* settlement before trial of a complex design and construction defect case Stark & Stark took over from another law firm involving a 460 unit condominium with severe water infiltration and structural deficiencies;
- $4,250,000* settlement achieved during transition negotiations in a complex condominium construction defect case involving EIFS, decks, dormers and other common elements;
- $3,000,000* settlement before trial of a complex construction deficiency case against over 20 defendants involving claims relating to EIFS, windows, doors, the sea wall, roofs, and structural damages to concrete decks constructed from concrete filigree slabs in a 50 unit condominium;
- $1,650,000* settlement at trial of claims against 6 defendants relating to EIFS, framing, the fire suppression system and structural issues in a 48 unit condominium;
- $1,600,000* settlement before trial of claims against 8 defendants relating to structural issues, decks, roofs and EIFS in a 2 story condominium;
- $1,390,000* settlement before trial of claims relating to deficient installation of stucco and stone on 69 single family homes;
- $1,300,000* settlement before trial of claims relating to deficient installation of a brick exterior cladding system on a 6 story mid-rise building;
- $1,000,000* settlement at trial of claims against multiple defendants relating to structural issues caused by severe site drainage deficiencies.
- Successfully defended large developer of a 125 unit townhome development in Park Ridge, New Jersey, against claims of deficient EIFS, brick and shingle roofing, including prosecuting declaratory judgment action on behalf of developer against its insurance company.
- Successfully defended general contractor and developer of a 61 unit condominium development in Eatontown, New Jersey, against claims of deficient brick and vinyl cladding, storm sewer system defects, and fraudulent concealment of environmental conditions.
Click here to sign up for Stark & Stark’s Community Association Times Newsletter to stay informed about industry news and events.
*Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.