Recently, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals for the State of New York issued a significant decision clarifying how “takings” provisions in commercial leases operate when government orders shut down a tenant’s business. See, Delshah 60 Ninth, LLC v. Free People of PA LLC (May 5, 2026), This decision is significant because it broadens the scope of a tenant’s argument to not pay rent in circumstances other than a force majeure event.
Background:
In March of 2020, the State of New York issued emergency shutdown orders in response to COVID-19. Free People of PA LLC, a Manhattan-based retail clothing tenant, stopped paying rent based on its lease agreement’s “takings” language. In response, Delshah 60 Ninth, LLC, Free People’s landlord, terminated the lease and sued for unpaid rent. Free People counterclaimed for wrongful termination and return of mistaken post-termination payments.
The District Court ruled in favor of Delshah, finding convincing the fact that Free People used the leased premises to store inventory and fulfill online orders and was, therefore, not deprived of all use and occupancy of the store.
The Second Circuit reversed based on the takings provision of the lease. The takings provision excused rent if Free People was:
“denied or deprived of either the use, occupancy and/or enjoyment of the Leased Space and/or the ability to operate its business thereon or therefrom by action or decree of any lawful power or authority…”
The Court treated “ability to operate its business” as distinct from mere use/occupancy. Because Free People’s business was a brick-and-mortar retail store (not a fulfillment center), limiting operations to online fulfillment meant it could not operate its business as contemplated by the clause.
Key Takeaways for Landlords:
The Second Circuit’s decision serves as a reminder that:
Here to Help:
If you are a landlord in New York and need assistance with your leases or want more information on how this decision impacts your leases, Stark & Stark’s Commercial Real Estate Transactions group and Litigation and Shopping Centers group can assist you.
Ryan Duffy is part of the Commercial Real Estate Transactions group at Stark & Stark frequently drafts and reviews commercial leases for commercial landlords in New York and New Jersey.
Ryan Wintermute is in the Litigation and Shopping Centers group at Stark & Stark, representing commercial landlords in New York and the tri-state area in enforcing commercial leases.
Bruce H. Stern, Esq. Secures $5.5 Million Settlement for Traumatic Brain Injury Victim
Stark & Stark is pleased to announce that Shareholder Bruce H. Stern, Esq., Certified Civil Trial Attorney and member of the firm’s Accident...“Best Law Firms” 2027 List Issued by Best Lawyers Recognizes Stark & Stark PC
We are proud to announce that the firm has been included in the 2027 Edition of Best Lawyers “Best Law Firms®” list, earning 11 regional...Bruce H. Stern, Esq. Secures $950,000 Settlement for Traumatic Brain Injury Client
Stark & Stark is pleased to announce that Shareholder Bruce H. Stern, Esq., Certified Civil Trial Attorney and member of the firm's Accident...Evan J. Lide, Esq. Secures $2.15 Million Wrongful Death Settlement
Stark & Stark is pleased to announce that Shareholder Evan J. Lide, Esq. recently secured a $2,150,000 settlement on behalf of the family of a...Stark & Stark Attorneys Recognized as New Jersey “Super Lawyers” and “Rising Stars” in 2027
Stark & Stark is pleased to announce that 16 of its attorneys have been selected for inclusion in the list of 2027 New Jersey Super Lawyers,...Stark & Stark’s Chinsu Shajan, Esq. Receives Mercer County Bar Association Rising Leader Award
Stark & Stark is proud to announce that Chinsu Shajan, Esq., a Shareholder in the Firm’s Accident & Personal Injury Group, was honored by...