• People

    Advanced Search

  • Services
  • All Services

  • Back to News & Media
    Blog

    Cybersecurity Lawsuit Against NJ Hospitals Highlights the Need for Protection Against-and After-Data Breaches

    January 11, 2024

     Download as PDF

    Healthcare providers are responsible for guarding the health and well-being of their patients. Still, they also have an essential duty to protect the personal information they collect in the process.

    And precisely because doctors’ offices, hospitals, and other health service providers handle so much personal information, they can be the target of attacks by cybercriminals. These attacks have been on the rise, and businesses of all kinds need to take steps to protect themselves and their clients and respond appropriately when a breach occurs.

    A recent reminder came when a New Jersey company was hit with a class action suit after a data breach occurred in which patients personal data was exposed online, leaving them vulnerable to identity theft.

    The class action suit

    The company in question is Capital Health Systems, which owns hospitals in Trenton and Hopewell, New Jersey. It announced on November 29th that its data network had been targeted in a cyberattack, according to a suit filed on behalf of a putative class of individuals by the law firm Kopelowitz Ostrow Ferguson Weiselberg Gilbert.

    While Capital Health Systems allegedly failed to notify its patients of the data breach, some have already experienced repercussions. The only person named in the suit is a longstanding patient who has undergone treatments and surgeries at Capital Health Systems facilities and claims to have suffered losses due to the breach.

    The plaintiff and class representative claim to have experienced “damage and diminution in the value of private information, a form of property that Capital Health acquired from him; violation of privacy rights; and present, imminent and impending injury arising from the increased risk of identity theft and fraud.”

    This case is still being tried, and the outcome isn’t yet known, but it points to a serious liability for this company. CHS could be on the line for significant penalties and legal fees, which should concern all healthcare providers who handle sensitive patient information.

    How does a data breach at a hospital take a toll on patients?

    According to the suit, “Cyber-criminals can cross-reference two sources of PHI [Personal Health Information] to marry unregulated data available elsewhere to criminally stolen data with an astonishingly complete scope and degree of accuracy to assemble complete dossiers on individuals. These dossiers are known as ‘Fullz’ packages.”

    Because of this vulnerability, when hospitals are hacked into by cybercriminals, class action lawsuits often result, according to Law.com.

    The loss of PHI can be highly detrimental to individuals. These types of information can be broad, including but not limited to:

    • Billing information
    • Emails to your providers office about a prescription
    • Appointment scheduling confirmation with your doctor’s office
    • A CT scan results
    • Blood test results
    • Phone records

    Therefore, businesses, including healthcare providers, are responsible for guarding it from exposure, loss, and misuse. Its always recommended that these facilities follow data security best practices and have a comprehensive plan to respond to cyber threats, including regular data security audits.

    If a data breach occurs, companies must take swift action and engage legal counsel that can help them respond wisely to guard against lawsuits and other undesirable outcomes.

    Representation is the key

    Having a business attorney on your side is a proactive measure to mitigate damage after a data breach. Talking to an attorney in advance helps to avoid missteps like those of Capital Health, which didn’t immediately inform its clients of the breach.

    At Stark & Stark, our knowledgeable and compassionate lawyers have a proven record of representing New Jersey Clients in wide-ranging civil and criminal lawsuits.

    Contact us today to schedule a consultation.

    Firm Highlights

    Stark & Stark Shareholder Deborah S. Dunn, Esq. Installed as 2nd Vice President and Diversity Officer of the New Jersey Association for Justice for 2026–2027

    Stark & Stark is proud to announce that Shareholder Deborah S. Dunn, Esq. has been installed as 2nd Vice President and Diversity Officer of the...

    Stark & Stark Recognized with Community Partner Award by Mercer County Community College Foundation

    Stark & Stark is proud to announce that the firm has been recognized with the Community Partner Award by the Mercer County Community College...

    Carin A. O’Donnell, Esq. Inducted as 2026-2027 President of the Pennsylvania Association for Justice

    Stark & Stark is proud to announce that Carin A. O'Donnell, Esq. was sworn in as the 2026-2027 President of the Pennsylvania Association for...

    Stark & Stark’s Thomas S. Onder, Esq. Receives 2026 ICSC Trustees’ Distinguished Service Award

    Stark & Stark is proud to announce that Thomas S. Onder, Esq., Shareholder and Chair of the Firm’s Shopping Center & Retail Development...

    Stark & Stark’s Joseph H. Lemkin Esq., Named 2026 Professional Lawyer of the Year for the Jewish Bar Association of New Jersey

    Stark & Stark is proud to announce that Joseph H. Lemkin Esq. has been selected by the New Jersey Commission on Professionalism in the Law as...

    Our Values Remain: A Message on the Closing of Diversity Lab

    Stark & Stark is saddened and disappointed to learn that Diversity Lab, the organization that created and manages the Mansfield Certification...

    Congratulations to Shareholder Bhaveen R. Jani, Esq. on his Installation as Treasurer of the Middlesex County Bar Foundation

    Stark & Stark is proud to announce that Shareholder Bhaveen R. Jani, Esq. has been installed as Treasurer of the Middlesex County Bar Foundation,...

    Denise Mariani, Esq., and Jonathan Lauri, Esq. Secure $750,000 Jury Verdict Against Hamilton Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center

    It is our pleasure to announce that Denise Mariani, Esq., and Jonathan Lauri, Esq., secured a $750,000 jury verdict on behalf of a nursing home...

    Stark & Stark Welcomes 2026 Summer Law Clerks

    Stark & Stark is proud to announce its 10th Annual Summer Law Clerk Program. Five Summer Law Clerks will join the firm from June through July...

    Retail Development Team Secures Major Recovery for Landlord Client Amid Bankruptcy Dispute

    Our Shopping Center and Retail Development Group recently secured a multi-million-dollar settlement for a commercial landlord client' s property...

    Jeffrey A. Krawitz, Esq. and Catherine Foley, Esq. Secure $950,000 Settlement in Surgical Malpractice Matter

    Jeffrey A. Krawitz, Esq. and Catherine Foley, Esq. recently secured a confidential $950,000 settlement in a surgical malpractice case. “This...

    Victoria Wilton, Esq. Selected to Serve on New Jersey State Bar Association Family Law Executive Committee

    We are proud to announce that Victoria Wilton, Esq. has been selected to serve on the New Jersey State Bar Association Family Law Executive Committee...