• People

    Advanced Search

  • Services
  • All Services

  • Back to News & Media
    Blog

    A Gift or a Lawsuit? When Lifetime Transfers Become Probate Battlegrounds – Part 1

    May 5, 2026

     Download as PDF

    inter vivos gifts new jersey

    Inter vivos gifts – property transfers made during a person’s lifetime – are often intended to simplify estate administration, avoid probate, or provide immediate help to loved ones. In practice, however, lifetime transfers frequently become the most hotly contested issues in estate and probate litigation. When substantial assets change hands late in life, during serious illness, or without legal guidance, these transactions can spark disputes that rival, and sometimes eclipse, traditional will contests.

    A recent New Jersey Appellate Division decision, In the Matter of the Estate of David Buccafusca, issued on March 30, 2026, illustrates how lifetime transfers can quickly turn into lengthy and expensive litigation. The case centered on the ownership of a residential property in New Jersey and a deed that was executed less than twenty‑four hours before the property owner’s death. The decedent, David Buccafusca, was suffering from advanced cancer and receiving hospice care at the time he signed the deed transferring his ownership interest in the home to individuals who were living in the property.

    After Mr. Buccafusca’s death, his only child, acting as administrator of the estate, challenged the transfer. The estate argued that the deed was not a valid inter vivos gift and should be set aside because the decedent lacked the mental and physical capacity to understand the transaction and because the transfer was the product of undue influence during a period of extreme dependency. The estate further asserted that the circumstances surrounding the deed – its timing, the decedent’s condition, and the involvement of the recipients – raised serious questions about whether the transfer reflected the decedent’s true intent.

    Despite these concerns, both the trial court and the Appellate Division ultimately upheld the deed. The courts emphasized that a formally executed deed is strong evidence of intent and that suspicion alone, even when a transfer occurs shortly before death, is not enough to invalidate a lifetime gift. Without sufficient admissible evidence of coercion, domination, or a lack of capacity, the estate could not overcome the high burden required to undo the transfer.

    The Buccafusca case highlights a critical reality in estate planning and litigation: documents matter. Courts give significant weight to deeds and other written transfer instruments, even when they are executed under emotionally charged or unsettling circumstances. When evidence of undue influence or incapacity is thin, estates may lose disputes over valuable assets before they ever reach trial.

    For individuals engaging in estate planning, this case is a cautionary tale. Informal or last‑minute lifetime transfers can unintentionally disinherit family members and create conflict long after death. For executors and beneficiaries, it underscores how “non‑probate” assets can still become probate battlegrounds when intent is questioned and expectations collide. Thoughtful planning, clear documentation, and appropriate legal guidance are often the difference between a smooth transfer and years of litigation.

    In the next article, Part 2 of this series, we will explore how New Jersey courts evaluate claims of undue influence and confidential relationships in lifetime transfer disputes, when the burden of proof may shift to the recipient of a gift, and what steps can be taken during life to reduce the risk of post‑death litigation.

    Key Contact

    Jordan Inver, Esq. | New Jersey Trusts & Estates Attorney
    609.895.7300

    Firm Highlights

    Bruce H. Stern, Esq. Secures $5.5 Million Settlement for Traumatic Brain Injury Victim

    Stark & Stark is pleased to announce that Shareholder Bruce H. Stern, Esq., Certified Civil Trial Attorney and member of the firm’s Accident...

    “Best Law Firms” 2027 List Issued by Best Lawyers Recognizes Stark & Stark PC

    We are proud to announce that the firm has been included in the 2027 Edition of Best Lawyers “Best Law Firms®” list, earning 11 regional...

    Bruce H. Stern, Esq. Secures $950,000 Settlement for Traumatic Brain Injury Client

    Stark & Stark is pleased to announce that Shareholder Bruce H. Stern, Esq., Certified Civil Trial Attorney and member of the firm's Accident...

    Evan J. Lide, Esq. Secures $2.15 Million Wrongful Death Settlement

    Stark & Stark is pleased to announce that Shareholder Evan J. Lide, Esq. recently secured a $2,150,000 settlement on behalf of the family of a...

    Evan J. Lide, Esq. and J. Robert Bratman, Esq. Secure $1,250,000 Settlement for Injured Bicyclist Hit by Commercial Vehicle

    Stark & Stark is pleased to announce that Shareholders Evan J. Lide, Esq. and J. Robert Bratman, Esq., both Certified Civil Trial Attorneys and...

    Stark & Stark Attorneys Recognized as New Jersey “Super Lawyers” and “Rising Stars” in 2027

    Stark & Stark is pleased to announce that 16 of its attorneys have been selected for inclusion in the list of 2027 New Jersey Super Lawyers,...

    8 Ways to Support a Loved One Living With Dementia

    If someone you love is living with Alzheimer's or another form of dementia, you already know how much the small moments matter. How you greet them,...

    Stark & Stark’s Chinsu Shajan, Esq. Receives Mercer County Bar Association Rising Leader Award

    Stark & Stark is proud to announce that Chinsu Shajan, Esq., a Shareholder in the Firm’s Accident & Personal Injury Group, was honored by...

    Michael H. Foster, Esq. and Stephen M. Di Stefano, Esq. Secure $5.5 Million Settlement for Victim of Motor Vehicle Crash

    Stark & Stark is pleased to announce that Michael H. Foster, Esq. and Stephen M. Di Stefano, Esq., both Certified Civil Trial Attorneys and...

    Stark & Stark Welcomes Nicholas Giaquinto

    Stark & Stark is pleased to welcome Nicholas Giaquinto as a Law Clerk in the firm’s Banking & Financial Services Group and Commercial...

    Stark & Stark Welcomes New Associate Michael Diaz, Esq.

    Stark & Stark is pleased to welcome Michael Diaz, Esq. as a new Associate in the firm's Accident & Personal Injury Group.  Before joining...

    Stark & Stark Welcomes New Associate Alex Miller, Esq.

    Stark & Stark is pleased to welcome Alex Miller, Esq. as a new Associate in the firm's Accident & Personal Injury Group, where he will...