It is now finally safe to say that New Jersey’s “Fireman’s Rule” which prevented lawsuits by first responders is dead. In 2006, the Appellate Courts of New Jersey recognized and upheld the Fireman’s Act signed into law by former Governor Jim Florio in 1995. This law gives a right of recovery to first responders for injury or death which might be either “directly or indirectly the result of neglect, willful admission, or willful or culpable conduct of any person or entity, other than the law enforcement officer, firefighter or first aid ambulance or rescue squad member.”
At it’s core, this Act allows first responders to sue property owners for injuries caused by unsafe conditions encountered responding to an emergency.
The benefit to the first responder is that it creates an additional right to sue for injury, pain and suffering, and death over and above any benefits such as workers’ compensation or those provided by the pension system.
An owner of a premises has a duty to take such steps as a reasonable and prudent person would view to correct or give warning of hazardous conditions or defects actually known to the owner, and of hazardous conditions or defects which the owner, through the exercise of reasonable care, could discover.
To recover for negligence against a property owner, someone must first prove that the property was in defective condition; that the existence of that condition was known or should have been known to the owner; that the owner failed to act reasonably under the circumstances; and, that the injuries suffered was proximately caused by that defect.
Someone injured by a defective product can sue its manufacturer either because the product was defective in its design, defective by manufacture, or the product failed to contain adequate warnings of its hidden or not so hidden dangers. Of course, many products can be intentionally misused to cause injury and some products by their very nature will present hazards such as a knife. Anyone injured by a defective product should first keep the product and not alter it or change it in any way. This includes the materials that came with the product, such as booklets or instructions in the packages.
There are some recent examples where first responders have been allowed to sue for injuries. These include a police officer struck by an impaired driver at a DWI stop; a police officer injured by debris on the floor of a warehouse while responding to an alarm at night; a police officer being assaulted while responding to a domestic violence complaint; a firefighter suffering smoke inhalation while fighting a fire caused by a vandal setting fire to improperly stored paint cans; or firefighter injured while trying to put out a fire started by an improperly maintained gas grill.
Stark & Stark as your civil attorneys stands ready to assist first responders and their families with a full array of investigative and legal resources to protect the rights of first responders especially from the negligence or actions which may cause your injuries.
We at Stark & Stark know that figuring out the benefits and regulations for injured or sick public employees is a difficult, time consuming, and often confusing process. Stark & Stark has a group of lawyers, supported by a team of paralegals who practice only in the workers’ compensation area for clients injured on the job. These injuries may include traumatic accidents, occupational diseases, and injuries caused by toxic substances or even stress. Our lawyers will make sure you receive all the benefits available to you including lost wages, payment of authorized medical expenses, and, if appropriate, a cash award for your injuries. If you have any questions, do not hesitate to give us a call.
"*" indicates required fields
Stark & Stark Attorneys Recognized as New Jersey “Super Lawyers” and “Rising Stars” in 2026
Stark & Stark is pleased to announce that 15 of its attorneys have been selected for inclusion in the list of 2026 New Jersey Super Lawyers,...Bruce Stern, Esq. Secures $1,000,000 Settlement in Motor Vehicle Collision Case
Bruce Stern, Esq. recently secured a $1,000,000 settlement in a motor vehicle collision case.* “This case highlights how quickly things can go...Deborah Dunn, Esq. Elected to Board of Directors for Angel Flight East
Stark & Stark is pleased to announce that Deborah Dunn, Esq., Shareholder and Civil Trial Attorney, has been elected to the Board of Directors...Michael Jordan, Esq. Joins the Board of the Lawrence Township Community Foundation
It is our pleasure to announce that Michael Jordan, Esq. has joined the board of the Lawrence Township Community Foundation, an organization...Joseph Lemkin, Esq. Named to ROI-NJ Influencers: Power List 2026 – Law
Stark & Stark is proud to share that Joseph Lemkin, Esq., Shareholder, has been named to the 2026 Influencers: Power List in the Law category...Joseph Cullen, Esq. and Nicole Durso, Esq. Secure $2,000,000 Settlement in Personal Injury Matter
Joseph Cullen, Esq. and Nicole Durso, Esq. recently secured a $2,000,000 settlement in a personal injury matter involving a pedestrian who was struck...James Creegan, Esq. Appointed to Board of The 200 Club of Mercer County
It is our pleasure to announce that James Creegan, Esq. has been appointed to the Board of Directors of The 200 Club of Mercer County, an...